I always completely turn off my cellphone when I enter a theater. Not just on vibrate – totally powered down. I share this not to boast, or to suggest that the spirit of a classic director will appear to offer approval. I see it as a simple little pleasures: for a minimum of ninety minutes, I exist as totally incommunicado. I keep my phone deactivated for the duration of the scroll as well. It strikes me as luxurious to stay put as the audience slowly filter out, lit only by the scrolling names.
And, more and more, by the glow of the Letterboxd app.
In excess of twenty-six million users utilize Letterboxd, a movie-logging application. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a specific type of influencer who promotes latest films and finds joy in unearthing vintage films. Users rate and review films, and the most insightful or most illuminating reviews become popular, encouraging film lovers to write diligently.
"Should I fail to get my thoughts out immediately when the film concludes, my reviews are significantly less lucid and well-put," said Josh Stern.
On a recent visit to the theater, the credits had barely started before the man seated in front of me started composing his thoughts. Nearby, a duo lingered, looking down, recording their personal reactions.
The legendary film-maker David Lynch shared some advice: record every brilliant thought the precise instant it comes to mind. If you don't, it could slip your mind, and, as he phrased it: "Forgetting a great idea, you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, a similar ethos fits the post-film ritual.
Josh Stern, a 20-year-old student in New York, invariably writes his assessments from his theater seat.
"If I don't jot down my ideas quickly once the movie ends, my critiques are significantly less clear and eloquent," he said. "It takes some time. I'm pretty slow, and my partner gets impatient."
He visits the movies often – 182 times last year – and is on a friendly footing with the ushers, who at times must usher him out so they can start tidying the theater. He thinks it reasonable to utilize the credit sequence: "When you purchase a movie ticket, the end titles are included in the feature."
Letterboxd's most passionate advocates attribute the platform with rekindling enthusiasm around a battered movie business, where fewer films are made and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also possesses the type of audience data advertisers desire – its largest cohort of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Buzz creates further excitement; eagerly anticipated movies see a rash of reviews on Letterboxd right after the initial screenings. The top critique of a recent movie – "Emily Brontë passed away in the 19th century yet this adaptation is still the most egregious event that has ever happened to her" – has amassed in excess of 50,000 likes. A separate fictionalized retelling produced this comparison to a pop star's documentary: "the Eras Tour documentary found dead."
"It's a little a compulsion," said Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old New Yorker who has a career in marketing. He also likes to compose critiques during the closing scroll. "Reflecting on what you just witnessed, immediately after you saw it, helps with the viewing experience. It aids in understanding the central themes of a film. If it produces a sensation of comfort, that's hardly something you recall five hours down the line."
Glidden feels most motivated to review a film if it was brilliant – or terrible. Case in point: he recently watched a sci-fi film. "I was actually so offended by how profoundly awful it was, that I was excited to whip out my phone and give it a lowest possible rating," he said. (This reviewer is a tougher critic than other reviewers, who assigned the film a more favorable review, labeling it "smart and entertaining stuff.")
Another user, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who is in social media, saw an acclaimed animated film at a local theater and lingered to compose the assessment ("it received the highest rating"). He has clocked worse behavior: people whipping out their phones to review the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That behavior irritates me," he said.
One of the movie industry's most persistent myths recounts a screening of an 1896 silent short that featured a train pulling into a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – in line with this debunked story – the shot of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera shocked the audience so much that people scattered in panic.
Over a century later, cinema etiquette remains just as poor. Apparently, few people understand how to conduct themselves any more, particularly when the theater darkens: audience members snap photos of the image, carry in odorous food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, sometimes get into fights.
Certain people have resorted to social media to discuss the propriety of writing reviews in the closing scroll. When one social media user